Ok for items:

Broad Sword: 7/10, Its a good sword but not for the replacement, - Improve with about 1 pixel thinner blade and probly a better design/shading on handle.

Fish: Really good 9/10, better than normal one, should be blue?Lol

Pie:4/10 Sorry, i dont know what it looks like but not a pie, i cant see shading really but could be better.

FH: 7/10 its ok but looks a bit well not like a hammer or pick axe..

IH:DITTO ^^^^

Xtals: 1st new xtal is best but 2nd new one is bit wierd.

Miners don't always mine perfect crystals/rocks/ect. >.>

I'll only give a comment for my favourite:

Crystals:
3rd version looks more like a real crystal, since crystal is usually in shards, & doesn't look neat like a gem (how FSO ones look)
only thing imo needs editing the tiniest, is probably that it needs a shine to it, like a lighter shade somewhere on it, in the apropriate place/s.
9/10

(the 1st edited ones you made have really nice colour, but look too neat, that's why I like the sharded version you made best)

- Lu

Hyper-realism isn't always necessary in video games. Games are a way to get AWAY from actuality. The 1st remake is good, but the blue one is colored...badly somehow. 2nd remake looks doofy.

guess he didnt like mine...again

Post the second coloumn of crystals in his topic that he made, maybe he will pick it. You can't expect him to see every topic.

which? the first xtal resprite or second xtal resprite?

I think the second row is good, just fix the blue one, it has too much white.
sh33p

Broadsword, fish and 2nd crystals are awesome. Pie is OK, so are hammers, but why pickaxes?

pick-axes were suggested in another thread...i used the colors from the original xtals just made a new shape...and the hammers are the ones in the game...i just made them into picks